Home

Explore the best Christian fantasy.

articles | news | library | reviews | podcast
Advertise Seek Review Questions?

Nomad
Reviews | Lorehaven Review Team on Mar 5, 2021

Legend of the Storm Sneezer
Reviews | Lorehaven Review Team on Mar 5, 2021

53. How Can Christian Fans React When Fantasy Creators Get Cancelled? Part 1
Podcast | Fantastical Truth on Mar 2, 2021

My Novel ‘The Mermaid’s Sister’ Arose from True Depths of Mourning
Articles | Carrie Anne Noble on Mar 1, 2021

The Icarus Aftermath
Reviews | Lorehaven Review Team on Feb 26, 2021

My Screenwriter Mom Introduced Me to Fantastic Sci-Fi in the 1960s
Articles | Jason William Karpf on Feb 25, 2021

52. Do Christians Really Need Science Fiction? | Fiction’s Chief End, part 3
Podcast | Lorehaven on Feb 23, 2021

Join Our March 11 Livestream Exploring Christian Reactions to Fandom Cancel Culture
News | Lorehaven on Feb 22, 2021

The Hourglass and the Darkness
Reviews | Lorehaven Review Team on Feb 19, 2021

Venus is More Than Just a Love Goddess
Articles | Shannon Stewart on Feb 18, 2021

Introducing Fantasy Enthusiast and New Lorehaven Writer Shannon Stewart
News | Lorehaven on Feb 17, 2021

Stories with Bad Ideas Can Still Help Us Grow
Articles | L.G. McCary on Feb 15, 2021

Gretchen and the Bear
Reviews | Lorehaven Review Team on Feb 12, 2021

The Mandalorian is a Religious Fundamentalist, and Here’s Why That’s Awesome
Articles | Josiah DeGraaf on Feb 11, 2021

Introducing Fantasy Creator and New Lorehaven Writer Josiah DeGraaf
News | Lorehaven on Feb 10, 2021

51. Do Christians Really Need Fantasy? | Fiction’s Chief End, part 2
Podcast | Fantastical Truth on Feb 9, 2021

The Death and Rebirth of Magic in Children’s Fantasy
Articles | R. J. Anderson on Feb 8, 2021

Torch
Reviews | Lorehaven Review Team on Feb 5, 2021

Fictional Magic Systems Can Go Beyond Rules and Reveal Deeper Characters
Articles | Elijah David on Feb 4, 2021

How God Uses Story Villains for Our Good
Articles | Zackary Russell on Feb 3, 2021

Introducing Sci-Fi Creator and New Lorehaven Writer Zackary Russell
News | Lorehaven on Feb 2, 2021

50. Do Christians Really Need Fiction? | Fiction’s Chief End, part 1
Podcast | Fantastical Truth on Feb 2, 2021

Frank E. Peretti to Give Keynote Address at Realm Makers Writers Conference This July
News | E. Stephen Burnett on Feb 1, 2021

Fugue for the Sacred Songbook: In Eb Minor
Reviews | Lorehaven Review Team on Jan 29, 2021

How A Year Without Superhero Films Rebooted Our Universe
Articles | Jason Joyner on Jan 28, 2021

New Book ‘Reading Evangelicals’ Will Focus on Famous Christian Fiction
News | E. Stephen Burnett on Jan 27, 2021

Introducing Superhero Novelist and New Lorehaven Writer Jason C. Joyner
News | Lorehaven on Jan 27, 2021

49. How Can We ‘Terraform’ the Church to Enjoy Fantastic Fiction?
Podcast | Fantastical Truth on Jan 26, 2021

Militant Secularism Could Force Christians to Create New Subcultures
Articles | Mike Duran on Jan 25, 2021

Flight of the Raven
Reviews | Lorehaven Review Team on Jan 22, 2021

Library

Find fantastical Christian novels

fantasy | sci-fi | supernatural and beyond
All novels Search Add a novel
Explore all: Middle-grade books | Young-adult books | Adult books
The Mermaid's Sister, Carrie Anne Noble
Etania's Worth, M. H. Elrich
Cinderella Spell, Laurie Lee
When Desperate Measures Are All You Have Left, J. C. Morrows
Fractures, James C. Joyner
Torch, R. J. Anderson
The Terran Summit, Anna Zogg
The Xerxes Factor, Anna Zogg
The Paradise Protocol, Anna Zogg
The Awakened, Richard Spillman
The Ascension, Richard Spillman
Love's Sacrifice, Kelsey Norman
Unbroken Spirit, Kelsey Norman
Seed: Judgment, Joshua David
Reviews

Find fantastical Christian reviews

All reviews Request review Share review

Nomad
“R. J. Anderson’s fantasy Nomad is a rollicking read with fascinating conflicts and plot twists.”
—Lorehaven on Mar 5, 2021

Legend of the Storm Sneezer
“Teen readers fond of lengthy, lighthearted ghost-and-zombie tales will enjoy Legend of the Storm Sneezer by Kristiana Sfirlea.”
—Lorehaven on Mar 5, 2021

The Icarus Aftermath
“Arielle M. Bailey’s The Icarus Aftermath spins a golden yarn of vivid characters and gripping emotion, set in a world ripe for exploration.”
—Lorehaven on Feb 26, 2021

The Hourglass and the Darkness
“Kyle L. Elliott’s novel The Hourglass and the Darkness posits a world before the great Flood, starting a promising series.”
—Lorehaven on Feb 19, 2021

Podcast

Get the Fantastical Truth podcast

Apple | Google | All subscribe links
Archives Feedback

53. How Can Christian Fans React When Fantasy Creators Get Cancelled? Part 1
Fantastical Truth, Mar 2, 2021

52. Do Christians Really Need Science Fiction? | Fiction’s Chief End, part 3
Fantastical Truth, Feb 23, 2021

51. Do Christians Really Need Fantasy? | Fiction’s Chief End, part 2
Fantastical Truth, Feb 9, 2021

50. Do Christians Really Need Fiction? | Fiction’s Chief End, part 1
Fantastical Truth, Feb 2, 2021

Webzine

Browse back issues (2018–2020)

Order back issues online!
SpecFaith

The original SpecFaith: est. 2006

site archives | statement of faith
New articles Questions? Pitch to us

The Fantastical Elements of Romantic Fiction, part 2
Parker J. Cole, Mar 4

Settling the Solar System in Science Fiction, part 3: the Moon
Travis Perry, Feb 24

The Fantastical Elements of Romantic Fiction, part 1
Parker J. Cole, Feb 17

Settling the Solar System in Science Fiction, part 2: Venus
Travis Perry, Feb 11

Beyond

Find more from Christian creators

Order the book! E. Stephen Burnett

Get exclusive shirts and beyond
in the Lorehaven store

Explore the book The Pop Culture Parent: Helping Kids Engage Their World for Christ

Does ‘Engaging Popular Culture’ Include Right-Wing Talk Radio?
E. Stephen Burnett, Oct 9

Join My Livestream This Thursday: Seven Ways to Find Truth in Fantastic Stories
E. Stephen Burnett, Oct 6

Home
Library
Reviews
Podcast
Webzine
SpecFaith
Store
Beyond Edit content
Lorehaven serves Christian fans by finding the best of Christian fantasy. Our free webzine, an online library, positive reviews, a thriving blog and community, and weekly podcast episodes help fans explore fantasy, science fiction, and other fantastical genres for the glory of Jesus Christ.
Subscribe free to Lorehaven
/ Articles

Wonder Woman 1984 v. Disneyfied Imagination: A Spoiler-Filled Defense

Some critics pretend like superhero movies are mainly about wish-fulfillment, but Wonder Woman 1984 directly challenges this idol.
Anthony G. Cirilla on Jan 5, 2021 | 2 comments

Many negative reviews of Wonder Woman 1984 have an undergirding belief: that superhero films are meant to help fans indulge in wish-fulfillment.

Notice: To explore what the film actually means to do, we must indulge in full spoilers for Wonder Woman 1984.

I think this is why the film’s “monkey’s paw” motif, the wish-granting Dreamstone, strikes one reviewer as “hackneyed.” The film paradoxically asks us to both appreciate the wish as a fundamental aspect of human dignity, and realize that our wishes must be relegated by a hierarchy of values.

Even positive takes on Wonder Woman 1984 often characterize the film as escapist. So the story’s exploration of wishes strikes some viewers as an ugly redundancy, like Aladdin wishing for more wishes.

But I think this Disneyfied view of the superhero genre is exactly what Wonder Woman 1984 sets out to refute—and I think the film refutes this escapism in a most edifying manner.

What do I mean by ‘Disneyfied imagination’?

Let me start with a necessary caveat. I am a regular consumer of Disney movies. I bought my wife a Beauty and the Beast combination engagement and wedding ring because of the personal significance of the film to our relationship. So I am a fan of Disney.

But aren’t even the biggest Disney fans slightly troubled by the entertainment industry mogul’s hold on the market, even a little bit?

Art should always be a little bit questionable, a little bit suspicious. Art should have to earn our attention, not assume it. You don’t really believe that wishing upon a star, no matter who you are, will come true. But you watch the movies of a company that has imprinted that theme song in your head enough times that you’re probably hearing it now, based on my imperfect quotation.

Wonder Woman v. unhealthful wishes

Wonder Woman 1984‘s plot directly explores the assumption that superhero stories are about wish-fulfillment. When a new hire at the Smithsonian, Barbara Minerva, shares her confusion over an odd item in her new inventory with Diana Prince, Wonder Woman’s Amazon training kicks in. She quickly recognizes the Latin inscription on its outside: this is a wishing stone. Diana doesn’t believe this object actually holds mystical power. But she casually touches the stone and wishes for the impossible: that she could again be with the heroic Steve Trevor. Back in Wonder Woman [1918], Steve had helped Diana believe that the world of men outside of Themiscyra is worthy of love.

Wishing is a very important human power. It’s nigh-unextractable from the human imagination itself. In J. R. R. Tolkien’s “Mythopoeia,” his timeless defense of the role of imagination in making life meaningful, Tolkien wrote:

Whence came the wish, and whence the power to dream,

or some things fair and others ugly deem?

Tolkien contends that our very moral instinct depends upon the power to wish. But if that is true, it means we ought to be careful about how we use this power.

Critics have rebuked Wonder Woman’s indulgence in her relationship with Steve Trevor as irresponsible. But her lapse in responsibility actually happens much earlier in the film. Diana held a stone that claims to be wish-granting, when she knows that supernatural entities like the Duke of Deception exist. That she entertained the wish at all was an error—a very sympathetic, human error made by an Amazon who has begun to forget to think like one.1

Remember, wishing is still a human act. Your to-do lists are practical wishes. Degree programs are predicated on wishes about the future; inventions stem from wishes in technology; medicines begin as wishes of the healthcare community. Prayers are, at least in part, wishes surrendered to God’s providence. The superhero genre itself is based on a wish to be strong when we are weak, to be responsible when we are strong, to be reliable when we are responsible.

That is the lesson of Wonder Woman 1984‘s opening sequence. It’s one of the most inspiring sequences in the film. Youthful Diana has enjoined a harrowing gauntlet to prove herself against the older Amazons. But she’s knocked from her horse by a tree branch, and later denied her final spear-throw by a disapproving Antiope. This older Amazon warrior teaches Diana that ignoble short-cuts are the wrong way to pursue wish-fulfillment.

At first the lesson was lost on me. Frustrated, I gave my wife a slack-jawed look of outrage at Antiope’s interference, and my wife returned the sentiment with equal fervor. Only later did we realize that our identification with Diana had caused us to lose sight of Antiope’s wisdom.

“June 2020” [sic].

Wonder Woman v. unheroic wishes

The assumption that we only want identification with the superhero marks our failure to understand the genre.2 We don’t just wish to be better. We wish for others who are better, and we wish to admire them for it. Admiration is only partly identification mediated by wish-fulfillment: it is also a desire to find someone worthy of extraordinary gratitude.

One could say that Diana’s friend Barbara Minerva makes exactly this mistake. Barbara does not separate her admiration for Diana Prince from her desire to identify with Diana’s best qualities. Instead, Barbara wishes to be exactly like Diana—setting her on the path to become Cheetah, the film’s secondary but deeply compelling villain. She is already dangerous when she appears to match Wonder Woman’s power. Then, even worse, Barbara receives feral superpowers and a beastly form through Maxwell Lord’s insidious wish-granting exchange program.

Barbara wished away her own identity, and in the process loses touch with her imago Dei (image of God) as well. It’s a beautiful depiction, however unintended, of the Judeo-Christian understanding of evil.

Again, critics often suggest superhero stories work as mere wish-fulfillment, as if the genre is similar to Barbara Minerva’s resentment-fueled fantasy. I can’t say I often hear fans of superhero movies speak that way, at least not when speaking as fans. I suspect some of the disconnect arises when viewers look at these imaginative productions, rather than looking through them, a method offered by C. S. Lewis in “Meditations in a Toolshed.”

But I think the difference is greater. I think the indulgent wish-fulfillment theory is a projected attempt, or memory from younger years, to understand why people continue to enjoy the superhero genre.

Wonder Woman v. selfish wishes

In fact, the film’s villain Maxwell Lord is exactly the manifestation of this distorted wish-fulfillment. He wishes to be the wishing stone, so that, as long as you touch him, whether in person or through the television, with your wish, it will come true. That means he literally attempts to guarantee that all people, regardless of their expectations, can get what they want from him. But his deceptive wish-granting strips his beneficiaries of their dignity, in the same way denigrators of the superhero genre believe superhero stories already do.

This critical view of the genre says something like, “If I were a fan of such fare (and that is a mighty big If), I would wish to be this preposterous hero.” But if that’s your strategy to experience the movie, and you find the movie so dissatisfying, perhaps it’s because you’re actually watching it the wrong way (the Maxwell Lord and Barbara Minerva way). You might as well believe the only way to enjoy pizza is when it’s cold, so you always eat pizza that way, and never enjoy it. Perhaps it is fatal to enter the superhero genre with such self-directed wishes. Perhaps it is instead better to start with the wonderful, imaginative premise that superheroes could be real.

It’s not the same premise to pretend you are a superhero and to pretend the superhero could be real. This is like not only believing you should not only eat your pizza cold, but believing everyone else prefers pizza that way. No wonder you think you don’t like pizza. You haven’t eaten it properly.

Wonder Woman 1984 can subvert our idolatrous wishes

Wonder Woman 1984 reminds us about the distinction between imagination and wishing. This distinction is vital, because the purpose of our imagination is to help our reason seek truth, when our desire-based wishes can be tempted by lies.

Wishes do not always stem from a place of good will, or from a full understanding of what we wish for. That’s a fact that Disneyfied imagination will smooth over with the image of wishing “upon a star.” But anyone who knows a bit about medieval astronomy knows the effects of stars are not always benevolent. (Just read C. S. Lewis’s Discarded Image.)

We live out our wishes with countless little choices directed at their fulfillment. But if we don’t discern between our wishes’ wisdom and ill will, do we know things will end as well as we unreflectively believe? Our imaginative efforts can help us to envision our wish-fulfillment writ large. And if we try this honestly, we might find there’s a monkey’s paw element to the wishes we pursue every day.

In the film, that is the point of Wonder Woman’s major moral failing. When she realizes this, it drives her toward her most moving sacrifice of repentance. That’s how Wonder Woman 1984 pushes us to identify with Diana Prince’s motivations in making her wish, then pulls us to the conviction that she needs to renounce the wish. Meanwhile, the film challenges us to ask how our own wishes have gone wayward. Are there lies about our moral duties underlying our actions? Probably. And we can only reform our actions after we begin surrendering our wishes to higher values.

The purpose of the imagination is not to merely make our wishes come true, but to make our souls long for the truth. I certainly don’t wish to be Wonder Woman, and didn’t wish this while watching the movie. But pretending that Wonder Woman 1984 was true reminded me to hate my convenient lies—or, you might say, my performative wishes. Wishing upon a star, or a Dreamstone, is no match for wonder at the truth.

  1. By the way, I think it is a repugnant failure of sympathy to denigrate Diana for missing her beloved, as some critics of the film have done. ↩
  2. This isn’t the only way we misunderstand the superhero genre, but I can’t list all the other failings. ↩
Anthony G. Cirilla
Anthony G. Cirilla is an assistant professor of English at College of the Ozarks, where he teaches about British literature, J. R. R. Tolkien and fiction writing. He is a JV editor and resident weirdo at Bear Publications, and he lives with his beloved wife Camarie in Branson, Missouri.
Website |

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Pocket
  • WhatsApp
  1. Lavay Byrd says:
    January 5, 2021 at 10:16 am

    I actually liked Wonder Woman 1984 and its message of “be careful what you wish for”, and was quite shocked by so many negative reviews for the film! But reading this article definitely opened my eyes to the movie’s deeper message, and it made me appreciate the film (and Wonder Woman) all the more.

    There is so much truth in this article— how several of the characters reflect today’s society in so many different ways. It makes me thing of the lyrics to one of TobyMac’s songs “I don’t want to gain the whole world and lose my soul”. The more you wish for things (based on lies such as popularity, envy, hate, power, fear, greed, selfishness, etc.), the more you lose yourself— the YOU who God made you to be.

    Thank you so much for sharing this beautiful article!

    Reply
    • Anthony G. Cirilla says:
      February 23, 2021 at 2:56 pm

      I am sorry I didn’t see this sooner, but I am so glad you enjoyed the piece. My wife and I both felt very edified after leaving the theatre, so we were surprised about how much backlash it received. I’m glad there are people who feel as we do!

      Reply

What do you think? Cancel reply

  • Fictional Magic Systems Can Go Beyond Rules and Reveal Deeper Characte...Fictional Magic Systems Can Go Beyond Rules and Reveal Deeper Characte...
  • To Shape a Story is to Shape a SoulTo Shape a Story is to Shape a Soul
Lorehaven magazine, winter 2020

Wear the wonder:
Get exclusive shirts and beyond

Listen to Lorehaven’s podcast

Authors: Reach new fans with Lorehaven